Support For Families Facing an Erb's Palsy Diagnosis
Learning that your baby has Erb's Palsy can be heartbreaking and confusing. You may be worried about how this injury will affect your child's future, and you may also be asking whether something went wrong during labor or delivery. If you are looking for an Erb's Palsy attorney Austin families can turn to for answers, our team is here to talk with you.
At Howry Breen & Herman, LLP, we have spent nearly 25 years in courtrooms in Austin and across Central Texas representing people whose lives changed because of serious injuries. We handle complex medical negligence and catastrophic injury cases, and we apply that same trial strength when we investigate birth injuries like Erb's Palsy. Our goal is to help you understand what happened, what your legal options may be, and how a claim could support your child's long-term care.
Understanding Erb's Palsy & How It Can Happen During Birth
Erb's Palsy is a type of brachial plexus injury. The brachial plexus is a group of nerves near the neck that controls movement and feeling in the shoulder, arm, and hand. When these nerves are stretched, pulled, or torn during birth, a baby can lose strength or movement in the affected arm. Some children improve over time with therapy. Others may need surgery or may live with permanent limitations.
Parents often first notice that one of the baby's arms does not move like the other or that the arm is held at an unusual angle. Doctors may explain that the injury happened because the baby was large or because the shoulders became stuck during delivery, a situation sometimes called shoulder dystocia. Even with these explanations, many parents are left wondering if more could have been done in the delivery room to protect their child.
Common Ways Erb's Palsy Occurs During Delivery
There are several ways Erb's Palsy can occur during birth. If a baby's shoulder becomes lodged behind the mother's pelvic bone, the delivering provider must act quickly and carefully. There are established maneuvers to help free the shoulder while reducing strain on the neck and shoulder area. If excessive force is used on the baby's head or neck, or if proper steps are not taken when shoulder dystocia is recognized, the brachial plexus can be injured. In some situations, decisions about when to proceed with a cesarean section instead of continuing with a difficult vaginal delivery may also be important.
Not every Erb's Palsy diagnosis is caused by medical negligence. However, the only way to fairly evaluate what happened is through a careful review of prenatal care, labor and delivery records, and the actions of the medical team. Our attorneys work with qualified medical professionals to understand whether the care provided met accepted standards. We explain our findings in clear language so that you can make informed decisions about how to move forward.
Who May Be Responsible For an Erb's Palsy Injury
When parents reach out after an Erb's Palsy diagnosis, they often want to know who may be held accountable if a preventable mistake occurred. Births involve many people and moving parts, and responsibility can rest with one provider, several individuals, or an institution.
Potentially responsible parties can include obstetricians, midwives, nurses, and other staff who managed labor and delivery. If they failed to recognize risk factors such as a large baby, gestational diabetes, or prolonged labor, they may have missed warning signs that a different delivery plan was needed. If shoulder dystocia arose and they did not use appropriate maneuvers, or used excessive traction, that may be a factor in the injury.
Hospitals and birthing centers can also bear responsibility. These facilities are expected to have policies, training, and staffing levels that support safe deliveries. Issues such as inadequate staffing, poor communication between providers, or lack of training in responding to shoulder dystocia may contribute to negligent care. In some cases, group practices or clinics that employed the provider can also be part of a claim.
Evaluating responsibility in an Erb's Palsy case requires more than a quick review of a chart. It usually involves a detailed timeline of pregnancy and labor, analysis of medical decision making, and consultation with medical professionals in relevant fields. Our attorneys have handled complex negligence investigations for many years, and we bring that same disciplined approach to birth injury cases. We also make it a priority to explain these issues in a way that makes sense to you, instead of burying you in technical jargon.
What To Do After an Erb's Palsy Diagnosis
After your child is diagnosed with Erb's Palsy, you may feel pulled in many directions. You are trying to keep up with appointments and recommendations, and at the same time you may be thinking about your legal options. Taking a few practical steps can help protect your child's health and any potential claim.
Prioritize Medical Care & Documentation
Your first focus should be on your child's medical care. Follow up with the specialists your pediatrician recommends, which may include pediatric neurologists, orthopedic surgeons, and physical or occupational therapists. Ask questions about prognosis, treatment options, and what signs the care team is watching for over time. Keeping up with recommended therapy and evaluations can support your child's development and help document how the injury affects daily life.
It is also helpful to gather and keep copies of important records. These can include prenatal records, labor and delivery notes, operative reports if there was a cesarean section, neonatal intensive care records, and discharge summaries. If you receive written information about your child's diagnosis or therapy plan, store that in a safe place. You may also want to keep a simple journal or notes about your child's progress, the exercises you are asked to do at home, and any concerns you notice over time.
Be Careful With Forms & Early Offers
You should be cautious about signing forms provided by hospitals, clinics, or insurance companies that you do not fully understand. Some documents can authorize broad release of information or may be related to early settlements. Before agreeing to anything that discusses compensation or waivers of rights, it is wise to speak with an attorney who handles birth injury matters.
When you contact our firm, we can review the information you already have and explain what other records may be needed. We talk with you about timelines that apply to medical malpractice claims in Texas and what steps might be involved if you decide to move forward. There is no cost for this initial conversation, and we work to make it as straightforward and respectful as possible.
Compensation & Long-Term Needs in Erb's Palsy Cases
One of the hardest parts of an Erb's Palsy diagnosis is thinking about the future. You may be wondering how much care your child will need, what that care will cost, and whether they will face limitations in school, sports, or work. A legal claim cannot undo the injury, but it can be a way to seek resources that support your child's needs over time.
In an Erb's Palsy case, damages may include past medical expenses, such as hospital stays, specialist visits, and therapy costs. They may also include projected future costs for additional surgeries, ongoing therapy, adaptive equipment, and other forms of support your child may need. In some situations, damages can also address the impact that the injury may have on your child's ability to earn income in the future or to participate fully in daily activities.
Presenting these damages effectively requires careful planning. This often involves working with medical professionals and, when appropriate, life care planners or economists who help outline likely future costs. Our attorneys have a long record of handling catastrophic injury cases where lifetime planning is essential. The results we have achieved in those matters reflect our commitment to telling the full story of how an injury changes a life.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my child's Erb's Palsy was caused by medical negligence?
The only reliable way to assess whether negligence may have caused your child's Erb's Palsy is through a careful review of the medical records and circumstances of the birth. Warning signs can include difficult labor with shoulder dystocia, unexpected use of significant force during delivery, or risk factors that were not addressed with an appropriate delivery plan. However, these signs alone do not tell the full story.
When you contact our firm, we review prenatal and delivery records and usually consult with medical professionals who are familiar with accepted standards of care. We look at the decisions that were made, how quickly providers responded to complications, and whether safer options were available but not used. After this review, we explain our conclusions to you in clear terms and discuss whether a claim may be appropriate. This evaluation helps you move from guesswork to an informed understanding of what likely happened.
How long do Erb's Palsy cases usually take in Texas?
The timeline for an Erb's Palsy case in Texas can vary based on several factors, including the complexity of the medical issues, the number of parties involved, and the court's schedule. Many cases begin with an investigation and expert review that can take several months. If a lawsuit is filed, it typically proceeds through stages such as discovery, depositions, and possible mediation before reaching trial or settlement.
Our attorneys are familiar with medical malpractice procedures in this state, including requirements related to expert reports and deadlines for filing claims. When we discuss your case, we provide a general overview of what the timing might look like, given your particular circumstances. Throughout the case, we work to keep you informed about key milestones and any changes that affect the projected timeline.
What kind of compensation might be available for my child's Erb's Palsy?
Potential compensation in an Erb's Palsy case can cover both past and future harms related to the injury. This may include medical expenses already incurred, such as hospital stays, specialist visits, and therapy. It can also include the cost of future treatment, additional surgeries if needed, ongoing rehabilitation, and adaptive equipment that supports your child's independence.
In some cases, damages may also address the impact of the injury on your child's ability to work in the future or to enjoy certain activities. Each case is different, and the specific categories and amounts depend on the evidence. During our evaluation, we talk with you about what types of losses are present in your child's situation and how those may be presented as part of a claim.
Talk With Our Austin Trial Attorneys About Your Child's Erb's Palsy
If your child has been diagnosed with Erb's Palsy, you do not have to sort through medical records and legal questions alone. Speaking with an Erb's Palsy lawyer who understands both the medical and legal aspects of birth injury cases can help you get clearer answers and a realistic view of your options. Our team is here to listen to your story, review the available information, and discuss possible next steps.
When you contact us, you will talk with a firm that has nearly 25 years of experience representing families in serious injury and medical negligence matters in Austin and across Central Texas. We offer free consultations, and we work on a contingency fee basis so you do not pay attorney fees unless we recover compensation for your family. Reaching out for legal guidance is a way to protect your child's future and your right to accountability if a preventable mistake occurred.
To schedule a free consultation with our trial attorneys about a potential Erb's Palsy claim, call (512) 430-4844 or contact us online today.
I could not have found more caring people, better lawyers or a better law firm than Howry Breen & Herman.
M.A.
“We are so grateful they believed in us and partnered with us to handle this case!”
We don’t have enough words to describe how thankful we are for everything HBH did to win our business case for us. We are so grateful they believed in us and partnered with us to do it. They are amazing at what they do and we could not have had a better team. They made an enormous, positive difference for us and our business. I could not recommend them more highly.
J.K.
“We were always one step ahead!”
My lawyers at HBH were so smart and aggressive – we were always on offense and one step ahead. They just kept hammering and the other side had no answer.
T.B.
“Best in the Business, Strongly Recommend”
HBH went above and beyond to help out following a crisis. Over the course of a 3 year case, I was always kept in the loop by their amazing team. Their preparation and execution was flawless and made the whole process run smoothly. Cannot speak highly enough of their team and how they care for their clients. Will never recommend another personal injury firm besides HBH.
Since 1997, the "Lead Counsel Verified" status has been granted to attorneys who possess:
- The Right Professional Experience
- A Spotless Record
Law.com: Top 100 Verdicts 2024
Howry, Breen & Herman is proud to have been named a Tier 1, 2 and 3 Austin “Best Law Firm” in 9 practice areas by U.S. News – Best Lawyers® (“U.S. News” and BL Rankings, LLC). Law firms are selected for inclusion in this prestigious ranking based on a series of quantitative and qualitative criteria. Our specialty and tiers are listed here: https://bestlawfirms.usnews.com/profile/howry-breen-herman-llp/overview/36628
The Austin Bar Association was founded in 1893 as a nonprofit professional organization for attorneys. Its mission is to enhance the legal profession, administration of justice, and the community through education, networking, and public service.
Abota Foundation Patriot
Howry Breen & Herman, LLP was selected the Top Personal Injury Law Firm in Austin by Texas Lawyer, “Best of 2020”. The annual special supplement contains the results of Texas Lawyer readers’ poll, wherein readers cast their votes for the best providers of services and goods to the legal profession.
Attorney Sean Breen and Attorney Chris Lavorato placed in California’s Top 100 Settlements for 2019, as tracked by The Recorder and VerdictSearch.
Our law firm is proud to have been recognized in the Texas Verdicts Hall of Fame. Texas Lawyer in conjunction with VerdictSearch, recognize attorneys and law firms for their verdicts of $10 million or more. In 2011 Sean Breen was a Hall of Fame Award Recipient for the #1 Premises Liability Top Texas Verdict, awarded by Texas Lawyer, for the jury verdict award in the case VanDusen v. Aspen Square Management. In 2016 Sean Breen was inducted into the Texas Verdicts Hall of Fame, awarded by Texas Lawyer, for an outstanding verdict in Nester v. Textron.
Selection to America’s Top 100 Personal Injury Attorneys® is by invitation only and is reserved to identity the nation’s most exceptional litigators for high-value personal injury, catastrophic injury, wrongful death, product liability, and medical malpractice matters. HBH is proud that Sean Breen has been selected for this award. Less than one-half percent (0.5%) of active attorneys in the United States will receive this honor — truly the most exclusive and elite level of attorneys in the community. (2017-2022)
Best Lawyers - Lawyer of the Year | Personal Injury Litigation – Plaintiffs (by BL Rankings, LLC d/b/a Best Lawyers and Co., LLC)
Best Lawyers - Lawyer of the Year | Litigation - Trusts & Estates (by BL Rankings, LLC d/b/a Best Lawyers and Co., LLC)
Best Lawyers - Lawyer of the Year | Personal Injury - Plaintiffs (by BL Rankings, LLC d/b/a Best Lawyers and Co., LLC)
Lifetime Achievement selection to America’s Top 100 Attorneys® is by invitation only and is reserved to identify the nation’s most exceptional attorneys whose accomplishments and impact on the legal profession merit a Lifetime Achievement award. Selection is not achieved based on a single accomplishment or a single great year of success, but rather on a lifetime of hard work, ethical standards, and community enriching accomplishments that are inspiring among the legal profession. Both Sean Breen (since 2017) and Randy Howry (since 2018) are honored to receive this award.
America’s Top 100 High Stakes Litigators® is reserved to identify the nation’s most exceptional trial attorneys in high value, high stakes legal matters. To be considered for selection, an attorney must have litigated (for either plaintiff or defendant) a matter (1) with at least $2,000,000 in alleged damages at stake or (2) with the fate of a business worth at least $2,000,000 at stake. These minimum qualifications are required for initial consideration. Thereafter, candidates are carefully screened through comprehensive Qualitative Comparative Analysis based on a broad array of criteria, including the candidate’s professional experience, litigation experience, significant case results, representative high stakes matters, peer reputation, and community impact in order to rank the candidates throughout the state. HBH is privileged to honor Partners Sean Breen (2017- 2022) and Randy Howry 2017, 2019, 2020 and 2021 for selection of this award.
Expertise - Howry Breen & Herman was recognized and featured in an article by expertisecommunity.com as one of the Best Real Estate Lawyers in Austin. 2020
America’s Premier High-Stakes Trial Lawyers®” – 7 Figure Litigators®, 8 Figure Litigators®, is meant to recognize the nation’s most respected and preeminent high-stakes trial lawyers based on their verifiable verdicts and/or settlements. It is a tremendous honor for Sean Breen (member since 2019) and Randy Howry (member since 2020) to be recognized among this elite group.
America’s Premier High-Stakes Trial Lawyers®” – 7 Figure Litigators®, 8 Figure Litigators®, is meant to recognize the nation’s most respected and preeminent high-stakes trial lawyers based on their verifiable verdicts and/or settlements. It is a tremendous honor for Sean Breen (member since 2019) and Randy Howry (member since 2020) to be recognized among this elite group.
The National Trial Lawyers – Top 100, a highly respected legal organization that limits its members to premier trial attorneys who demonstrate superior qualifications of leadership, reputation, influence, stature and public profile measured by strict qualification requirements. Sean Breen Top 100 Civil Plaintiff, since 2009.
Top 10 Business Tort Trial Lawyers by the National Trial Lawyers. Randy Howry 2012-2013; Sean Breen since 2016.
The Best Lawyers in America® recognizes the top 5% of the most skilled attorneys in the nation. The robust selection process requires attorneys to nominate and review fellow lawyers based on their ethics, skill, knowledge, and ability to obtain results for their clients. The Best Lawyers in America® list is a way for plaintiffs to identify the leading attorneys in their region, known for their ability to get results with honesty, strength, and skill. Tim Herman, Sean Breen & Randy Howry have been featured by The Best Lawyers in America® (consecutively from 2006-2023) running alongside some of the most qualified firms in the nation. More info here.
Top Attorneys As Published In Texas Monthly
Sean Breen has been recognized for obtaining the Number 1 Verdict in Texas for electrical injury and utility negligence. This win underscores his relentless commitment to achieving justice for his clients and showcases the firms dedication to exceptional advocacy.
Sean Breen was honored by TopVerdict.com for recovering one of the Top 50 Verdicts in Texas in 2017. This is an honorable distinction, reserved for those attorneys that achieve the highest settlements and verdicts in the state.
Sean Breen was honored by TopVerdict.com for recovering one of the Top 50 Verdicts in Texas in 2016. This is an honorable distinction, reserved for those attorneys that achieve the highest settlements and verdicts in the state.
Sean Breen has been a member of the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum since 2011, a renowned legal organization whose membership is restricted to trial attorneys who have achieved seven-figured settlements and/or jury verdicts.
Martindale-Hubbell® is widely regarded as one of the most renowned peer-review rating organizations in the legal field. Randy Howry (2018), Sean Breen (2001), Tim Herman (1998), and Glen Wilkerson (2014) at Howry, Breen & Herman have achieved the organization’s highest distinction of AV Preeminent®.
Each year, Super Lawyers® magazine publishes its list of peer-nominated/evaluated and independently reviewed attorneys. We are proud to have attorneys who have been selected for inclusion in the prestigious Texas Super Lawyers® List, by Thomas Reuters since 2003, running through 2020.
Membership in Top American Lawyers is limited to only 1% of all attorneys in the United States. Randy Howry is proud to be honored with a Lifetime Charter Membership in this exclusive organization (2017).
Randy Howry was honored by Austin Monthly’s Top Attorneys in 2023.